Board Members Are Not Hypothetical Constructs

It’s fairly common among board development writers and consultants to suggest that nonprofits take inventory of their current boards and develop lists of the skills, professions, and personal traits they need and want to add. Then (goes the conventional wisdom) put your list in priority order, and you’ll be ready to do board recruitment.

What a waste of time! What’s the point of identifying a desired outcome (“Someone wealthy, with lots of connections, who’s eager to do fundraising”) if there’s no way to accomplish that outcome? What’s the point of fantasizing about imaginary people (“Someone wealthy, with lots of connections, who’s eager to do fundraising”) when the point is to find real people and attract them to your cause?

The real process of board development takes place when an entire board sits down in a room and says, “Who do we know?” After the obligatory 10 minutes of “We don’t know anybody,” people will start saying, “Well, there is my cousin’s brother-in-law, who owns the copy shop on Fourth Street and has been looking for a board to join. ...” It may not be as glamorous as “Oprah,” but it has a lot more chance of producing community members who are willing to join and support your cause—and that’s what board members are.



Alliance for Children and Families and United Neighborhood Centers of America members have access to a variety of resources to help with board recruitment.

But if it’s so simple, why do most boards find it so hard? Because they neglect the essential first step: deciding what they truly want and expect board members—all board members, not just new recruits—to do. If you don’t write a job description, you’ll find it remarkably difficult to identify anybody who can do the job, and even more difficult to persuade someone to take it on.

This highlights yet another common error among boards that are trying to recruit: getting preoccupied with describing the job they want someone else to do. “We want a lawyer, and an accountant, and someone to do fundraising, and someone to write our newsletter”—no. What you need are people who will join you in identifying and assigning all the tasks a board must do to keep your agency healthy.

Maybe it’s best to use a board member as your lawyer; maybe it’s better to hire a lawyer. Ditto accountants. Ditto marketing professionals. What you must have are people who understand that they face not one but many tasks, and not individually but collectively—and the people you recruit will only understand that if you do. You are not seeking someone to fill a position; you are seeking someone to share with you the position you already occupy.

In other words, board members are not hypothetical constructs. They’re actual people who, in conjunction with you and other actual people you will recruit, will perform actual tasks in support of your actual institution. So proceed as follows:

  1. Identify those tasks, and write them down.
  2. Identify people who might be interested in supporting your agency, and then compare their known skills and abilities to the tasks you’ve identified.
  3. Go talk to those people! Even if half of them say no, the other half will say yes, and you’ll have a set of new board members—instead of another set of charts describing the board members you wish you had.

And let’s dispense with a favorite nonsensical quarrel between those who think you have to recruit people with passion for your mission and those who think you have to recruit people who have the ability to fundraise. The answer is both, and the other answer is that no one is born with either. If you talk to a stranger about your mission and he or she catches fire with it, he or she is eligible in the passion department, even if he or she hasn’t been a long-term supporter; enthusiasm is contagious, and of course you have it, right? By the same token, if you talk to someone who knows and loves you and says “I’ll do anything for you, but I don’t know anything about raising money,” the appropriate reply is, “Don’t worry, we’ll teach you.”

Raising money is nothing more than stating the case for an institution you love to people with the resources to support it. Board recruitment is nothing more than stating the case for an institution you love to people who will be prepared to do the same thing. Let’s stop complicating it, and preparing for it, and just get out there and do it.

Reprinted by permission of the author. This article originally appeared in Contributions Magazine Online. Free subscriptions are available to staff and volunteers of nonprofit organizations.  


Kelly Kleiman is principal of NFP Consulting, which provides board development, strategic planning, and fundraising services to nonprofit organizations and philanthropies. Through her consulting practice and in her guise as The Nonprofiteer, she has spent more than 20 years helping small- and mid-sized nonprofits organize themselves better and raise more money. These days she focuses especially on helping them create systems for using high-skill volunteers. 


Board Recruitment Resources

Alliance for Children and Families and United Neighborhood Centers of America members have access to a variety of resources to help with board recruitment:

  • Alliance Severson Center. The Alliance Severson Center connects members to a variety of resources related to board recruitment. In particular, its DocuShare database includes several useful articles, including “Matchmaker Make Me a Match” by Maureen Robinson, “Board Recruitment: By Design or by Default?” by Jannice Moore, and many others that can be found using the site’s search features. 
  • Nonprofit Director Online. Linking Mission and Money in Issue 4 – 2009 reviews whether the philanthropic culture of a nonprofit human service organization impacts the effectiveness of its board governance.
  • Fund Development Columns. Alliance for Children & Families Magazine columnist Bob Jones, president and CEO of Alliance member Children’s Aid and Family Services, Paramus, N.J., often writes about the role board members play in fund development. Read “Empowering Board Members to tell Your Agency’s Story” from Issue 3 – 2009 and “Development Basics to Survive Tough Times” in Issue 4 – 2009.